tktt: Are They “Spirits Of Light” Or “Goblins Damn’d”?

“Enq:  It is just what they say. But is it not very painful to her to be publicly denounced as “the most accomplished imposter of the age, whose name deserves to pass to posterity”, as is done in the Report of the “Society for Physical Research”?

 
Theo:  It might be painful if it were true, or came from people less rabidly materialistic and prejudiced. As it is, personally she treats the whole matter with contempt, while the Mahatmas simply laugh at it. In truth, it is the greatest compliment that could be paid to her. I say so, again.

 
Enq:  But her enemies claimed to have proved their case.

 
Theo:  Aye, it is easy enough to make such a claim when you have constituted yourself judge, jury, and prosecuting counsel at once, as they did. But who, except their direct followers and our enemies, believe in it?

 
Enq:  But they sent a representative to India to investigate the matter, didn’t they?

 
Theo:  They did, and their final conclusion rests entirely on the unchecked statements and unverified assertions of this young gentleman. A lawyer who read through his report told a friend of mine that in all his experience he had never seen “such a ridiculous and self-condemnatory document.” It was found to be full of suppositions and “working hypotheses” which mutually destroyed each other. Is this a serious charge?

 
Enq:  Yet it has done the Society great harm. Why, then, did she not vindicate her own character, at least, before a Court of Law?

 
Theo:  Firstly, because as a Theosophist, it is her duty to leave unheeded all personal insults. Secondly, because neither the Society nor Mdme. Blavatsky had any money to waste over such a lawsuit. And lastly, because it would have been ridiculous for both to be untrue to their principles, because of an attack made on them by a flock of stupid old British wethers, who had been led to butt at them by an over frolicksome lambkin from Australia.

 
Enq:  This is complimentary. But do you not think that it would have done real good to the cause of Theosophy, if she had authoritatively disproved the whole thing once for all?

 
Theo:  Perhaps. But do you believe that any English jury or judge would have ever admitted the reality of psychic phenomena, even if entirely unprejudiced beforehand?

 
And when you remember that they would have been set against us already by the “Russian Spy” scare, the charge of Atheism and infidelity, and all the other calumnies that have been circulated against us, you cannot fail to see that such an attempt to obtain justice in a Court of Law would have been worse than fruitless!

 
All this the Psychic Researchers knew well, and they took a base and mean advantage of their position to raise themselves above our heads and save themselves at our expense.”

 
H. P. Blavatsky

Leave a comment